Loading...
Monastic avoidance: Piety and ambivalence in pre-2016 Turkey
Tee, Caroline
Tee, Caroline
Citations
Altmetric:
Advisors
Editors
Other Contributors
Affiliation
EPub Date
Publication Date
2025-09-03
Submitted Date
Collections
Files
Loading...
Article - VoR
Adobe PDF, 651.35 KB
Other Titles
Abstract
Since the failed coup attempt in 2016, much academic attention has been devoted to the shadowy and now defunct political alliance between the AKP and the Hizmet community. Yet this scholarship only considers Hizmet as the level of its leadership and overlooks the core followers of Fethullah Gülen—mostly hard-working provincial schoolteachers and administrators. How did these individuals experience the movement’s controversial political dimensions (which were public for some years in advance of 2016) and make sense of it in the context of their daily lives of piety and hard work? In this paper, I present retrospective ethnographic observations from fieldwork undertaken in a Hizmet community in Turkey between 2013 and 2015 and argue for their relevance in understanding the community’s trajectory up to and including the present day. Specifically, I observe a tension in the lives of individuals who were committed to ethical Muslim living but were also implicated—if only through association with Fethullah Gülen—in Hizmet’s pre-2016 political agenda. Recent debates in the anthropology of Islam concerning the place of moral ambivalence in Muslim lives provide a starting point (Schielke 2010, Schielke and Debevec 2012, Fadil and Fernando 2015), whereafter I analyse Hizmet as a monastic community and argue that monastic practises allowed my interlocutors to balance competing empirical realities and maintain ethical coherence in their daily lives. I use the term ‘monastic avoidance’ to explain how Hizmet affiliates embedded themselves in tight-knit communities of piety in order to deflect their complicity in larger politico-religious projects that were associated with deception and illegality.
Citation
Tee, C. (2025). Monastic avoidance: Piety and ambivalence in pre-2016 Turkey. Contemporary Islam, vol(issue), pages. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11562-025-00589-w
Publisher
Springer
Journal
Contemporary Islam
Research Unit
PubMed ID
PubMed Central ID
Type
Article
Language
en
Description
© The Author 2025
The version of record of this article, first published in [Contemporary Islam], is available online at Publisher’s website: http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s11562-025-00589-w
The version of record of this article, first published in [Contemporary Islam], is available online at Publisher’s website: http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s11562-025-00589-w
Series/Report no.
ISSN
1872-0218
EISSN
1872-0226
ISBN
ISMN
Gov't Doc
Test Link
Sponsors
The ethnographic phase of research was made possible through funding from the John Templeton Foundation, grant ID 38749, administered by the University of Bristol (2013–2015).